....July 23, 11:55 AM
 
 
 
The Real Price Of Justice In New York


By By MICHAEL SCHENKLER

It has been a number whirlwind weeks of governing woes.

A number of us have been hammering away at the New York State Senate.

I would like to cling to the significant reform rules passed by the New York State Senate last week, but as Henry Stern points out below: “The new rules are riddled with exceptions, may or may not be applied in a particular instance, and can be changed at any time that the leadership feels they are in the way.”

So yes, we have seen the beginning of the reform movement but at this point it could be just another cosmetic stunt of Albany slight of hand.

The great reformers – Hiram Monserrate and Pedro Espada – were each paid off for returning to the Democratic fold. Hiram got his Committee Chairmanship and $12,500 stipend back and Pedro – the most ethically challenged member of the State Senate – was given $2 million in member items as his reward.

Reform?

Sorry, apparently in Albany, REFORM is just a six-letter word.

Now the City Council
And now, the disrepute of the Albany electeds is replicated in the City as Councilmember Miguel Martinez pleads guilty to pocketing some $100,000 in member items money.

Now this could be the start of something big – hum a few bars.

The New York Post points out: “Authorities are poring over the spending of about a dozen city and state legislators to see if they followed the same shady path of former City Councilman Miguel Martinez, who has admitted stealing from taxpayers, sources said yesterday.”

“One veteran government staffer said some people are already steering clear of the suspect legislators, fearing that anything they say could wind up in the hands of swarming prosecutors.”

Remember the beginning of the Council slush fund scandals?

The Speaker and her staff had been putting phony organization names in the City budget to squirrel away big bucks for her to dole out to be used to reward the members of her choice (and herself) to give away to their community favorites.

Sadly, to this date that crime – placing false information in the city budget – has gone unpunished. Apparently, the fact that Quinn was not pocketing any of the money got the authorities to look the other way.

As long as law enforcement does not act when public officials step over the line, they apparently will keep on crossing the line until law enforcement says, “enough.”

Councilman Martinez, is the beginning of the City Council’s “enough.”

And not soon enough for me.

BACK TO ALBANY
So the Senators – the Dems now in control — in addition to approving some $85 million in member items — $2 mil to Pedro, $77 mil to Dems – as part of their quick acts upon regaining control took care of some of their people in the early days of the coup. Eleven of the Senate’s highest-paid staffers received raises of up to $32,000 – a total of $200,000 annually — when it appeared likely Democrats would lose control.

Since then, dozens of staffers on both sides of the aisle have been given raises from $10,000 to $32,000 per year. The staffs of Senate Prez Pro Temp Malcolm Smith and Dem Conference Chair John Sampson seemed to have received the biggest payoffs for the five weeks of do-nothing Albany.

The day after the coup, two Senate Dem staffers received raises backdated to Jan 1 of some $32,000 bringing their salaries to $140,000.

The money has been flowing for member items and raises to favorites while the press releases herald the new reform rules.

REAL INJUSTICE
While the Senate, like the Assembly before them, divides up the spoils of the people’s treasury for their own benefit, they continue to withhold raises for the New York State Judiciary.

For the past decade, the NYS Legislature has believed that they can hold our judges salary’s hostage so that they may receive raises themselves.

At a July Fourth party, I chatted with a NYS Supreme Court Justice in the Tenth Judicial District. Now I know a number of Queens – Eleventh Judicial District – Justices, but enjoyed the perspective of my new friend.

His District includes all of Nassau and Suffolk County. Wow – an election nightmare, I thought as I started to probe what he needs to get re-elected for another 14-year term.

“I don’t think I’m going to run again;” he explained that he needed to make money. State judges have not received a raise – not even a cost-of-living increase — since 1997. And here was one judge who was preparing to leave the bench because the State Legislature cares more about games playing over their own salary increase than building and attracting a quality judiciary.

But there is a difference between the job of a judge and a state legislator.

Legislator is a part-time job; judge is full-time.

Legislators can hold other jobs and earn big bucks as many do; judges can’t.

Legislators benefit from hidden increases like stipends and per diem expense increases that they pass; judges sit with the same salary they had 11 years ago.

Remember, the legislature approved millions in members items and not one cent for judicial salaries.

I guess the little league team in Brian McLaughlin’s District is more important than a quality judiciary.

MSchenkler@QueensTribune.com

Michael Schenkler can be reached via this contact form.

 
 
Another Day of Shame: Martinez Pleads, Espada’s Pork

Henry Stern

By HENRY STERN

Last week, the News gave the downfall of Miguel Martinez most of its front page. A black box carries the message “Slush Fund Scandal, Who’s Next?”

The News’ editorial “Stop The Thieves,” includes these points: “Some people are just determined thieves. The question for the Council, most notably for Speaker Christine Quinn: Why make it easy for them? Martinez’ pocket-lining is an example of how corruption-prone the Council’s system of doling out so-called member items has become. Each lawmaker gets money every year to give to favorite groups under the loosest of controls.

$85 MILLION IN SENATE PORK
While justice appears to be on track for Martinez, far greater depredations take place daily – and nightly - in Albany. The Post: “Turncoat Is Served $2M,” by Fredric U. Dicker and Carl Campanile. “Switching sides – twice – and holding up state government for a month apparently has its privileges. Double double crossing (not a typo) Pedro Espada, Jr. won $2 million in pork-barrel spending for his district despite jilting the Democratic Party and grinding senate business to a halt during a leadership fight, documents released yesterday showed. The Senate Democratic leadership released a list of $85 million in “member item” grants after voting them in during a 3 a.m. session yesterday.”

The Post editorialized today on this topic, “Priority No. 1: Pork, Of Course.” “After weeks of tumultuous uproar and bitter partisan wrangling, state senators finally got their act together – and agreed on how to divvy up $85 million in special-interest pork spending… As for deciding vital outstanding issues, like who should run the city’s public schools, well, ‘We’re not in a hurry, says Queens Democrat Shirley Huntley, ‘I could be here forever.’ At least they’re clear about their priorities – however misguided.”

The primary business before the Senate was extension of mayoral control of New York City’s public schools, which expired on June 30. All the Republicans and about half the Democrats are committed to support the bill, which means it should pass easily. However, the Democratic leadership will not allow the bill to come to the floor of the Senate for an up or down vote. The reform package of rules changes approved at 4 p.m. is supposed to provide for bills to get a floor vote, rather than being blocked by a handful of senior members. However, the new rules do not apply in this case; it comes under three separate exceptions to the reformers’ rule.

The new rules are riddled with exceptions, may or may not be applied in a particular instance, and can be changed any time that the leadership feels they are in the way.

The new Senate rules did not affect the $85 million package of goodies just voted by the Senate, or the 30 percent increase for their staffs at a time when state employees are being laid off and judges have been denied even cost of living pay adjustments for 11 years.

They did not affect the $2 million slice of pork that Senator Espada received as a reward for his double back-flips. It did not affect mayoral control of the schools, being held up indefinitely by a Senate minority.

BTW, has anyone heard from Governor Paterson lately on any of these matters? Or from Attorney General Cuomo, who so quickly assailed the appointment of Richard Ravitch as Lieutenant Governor.

One begins, after a while, to empathasize (if empathy is still a tolerated virtue) with Lot, who was commanded to find a successively smaller number of honest and righteous men (sexism was endemic in that period) in Sodom and Gomorrah in order to save the town from destruction. Sadly, Lot was unable to do so. He was then ordered to flee the doomed city with his wife and not look back. Curious, his wife did look back, and on the spot she was turned into a pillar of salt.

The story is retold thousands of years after it may or may not have happened because it teaches obedience to God. Wherever the Lord may be, it is probably not Albany. People have to make their own way in deciding how to behave. We hope, along with Micah, that they do justly, love mercy and walk humbly with their God. If they do not, they deserve to be redistricted into the appropriate circle of Hell, but that outcome is highly unlikely.

StarQuest@NYCivic.org

Not4Publication.com by Dom Nunziato
Michael Schenkler can be reached via this contact form.