....July 16, 12:07 PM
 
 
 
Hiram, Amigos, Senators, Need To Make It Work


By MICHAEL SCHENKLER

Take Hiram Monserrate . . . please.

Seriously, in an hour-long phone conversation last week, the man who was for a brief moment the lynch pin in the Republican coup and now probably deserves credit for the Dem Majority, speaks as if much of the past month’s Albany fiasco was by design — planned by him and an amigo.

In the past, I‘ve referred to Hiram as a “bomb thrower,” crediting him with utilizing a tactic that disrupts, explodes, but usually causes change. Bomb throwers are not too popular with the elected status quo.

Hiram told me last week that he had no choice; Dem Leader Malcolm Smith was double talking him on the vacancy decontrol vote, the most important pending legislation to his district. Smith, he claimed, was dictatorial in the conference and the Senate needed to change. Hiram also insisted that the resources funded by the state – member items, district mailings, staff, etc. – must be more fairly distributed. No longer denying the minority party their fair share was an integral part of his reform.

Although he recognizes his alliance with Pedro Espada, a Senator with more ethical and potential criminal charges against him than Monserrate, raises eyebrows, “irrespective of all other things, he is innocent until proven guilty,” Hiram reminded us about Espada and himself. “There was no other way to change the leadership of the Senate,” Hiram insisted.

But to him, more important than leadership is empowering the individual senators: “The majority leaders should not have the power to block the will of the members of the Senate.”

And while I listened to Hiram, charming, quick, seemingly brighter each time we talk, and always street smart, I searched for other motives. Does this guy just like to throw bombs? Did Hiram get an unseen payoff? Is there something I’m missing? Or should I accept the word of Hiram, distrusted by many of his former Council colleagues, now certainly distrusted by most of his Senate colleagues – both parties – and under indictment for cutting his girlfriend?

Tomorrow may tell.

In the not too distant tomorrows, the Democratic Conference in which Hiram Monserrate is a pivotal vote must pass reform. The leadership must not be allowed to punish members for their votes of conscience; leadership must not be allowed to prevent member supported bills from getting to the floor, member items must be allocated fairly and evenly – considering the district’s needs not the juice of the member. Public resources must be made equally available to senators from both parties.

If that change does not happen and Hiram is sitting in his seat as part of the Democratic caucus and not throwing bombs, we’ll be back, in his face, telling it like it is.

On the other hand, is a Democratic Conference not too willing to share anything with the Republican Conference who tried to steal it all away? And, maybe you can’t blame the Dems. For the past four decades, the Republican Senators treated the Democratic Senators like second class citizens, denying them equality of just about everything. For Dems, smaller staffs, smaller offices, fewer mailings, a microscopic portion of member items was the GOP formula of doling out State resources.

So don’t let Republican Leader Dean Skelos fool you. He and his conference had their chance at reform and failed to act. For four decades they suppressed the minority Dems. And now that the demographic shift indicates the Dems will have future control, Skelos tries to take the high road after dwelling in the gutter of unfairness. These guys were willing to do business with the devil to steal back control.

And what have the Dems done? And what should they do?

Is fairness and even distribution of resources to the people more important that payback?

Are the Dems the better party? Will they do the right thing?

Will Hiram and his amigos force them to change for the better?

Or are they all just self serving, dishonorable elected officials fighting change?

Stay tuned, we’ll be watching.

Carrozza’s Shell game
And, then there’s the Assemblywoman with more houses than days she spends in Albany. It is amazing that Ann Margaret Carrozza is able to move the houses around, changing stories and addresses so quickly that you can’t see her lips move.

We know she hasn’t been living in her district office because she’s never there when we call.

We know she hasn’t been living in Albany; a fellow Assembly member tells us she’s up there perhaps one day a week when they are in session – as little time as any member. Somehow the old boys’ network covers up for members who spend more time on their law practice than their Assembly obligations.

And we know she hasn’t been living in her home where she is registered; it is rented to someone else.

So since February, Ann Margaret Carrozza, Assemblywoman from eastern Queens, has been living in her Glen Head home with her doctor husband and their children.

And get this, she won’t discuss her children. So we don’t have a right to know if they are going to a New York City public school, a Glen Cove upscale North Shore School school or private school.

So now after acknowledging at least five months out of the district, Carrozza gets a new address in the District. And we are supposed to beleive the shell game.

Oh, don’t expect the Assembly – who judges their members qualifications to even investigate. The Assembly is part of the same legislative body as the NYS Senate and plays by many of the same rules.

MSchenkler@QueensTribune.com

Michael Schenkler can be reached via this contact form.

 
 
Senate Dems Agree At Lowest Common Denominator

Henry Stern

By HENRY STERN

The Albany farce closed on its 32nd day with a complete victory for the hijackers.

Ending the month-long impasse, renegade Pedro Espada rejoined the Democrats, receiving a position he had previously been denied, Majority Leader Malcolm Smith was kicked upstairs to President of the Senate, while John Sampson became conference chair.

By executing his double double cross, Espada appears to be Master of the Senate, even though his colleagues, both Republicans and Democrats, may despise him. Many people didn’t like Stalin, either, but that didn’t stop him from ruling the Soviet Union until he died.

Governor Paterson comes out of this with a stronger hand, for finally acting to appoint a Lieutenant Governor to try to break the deadlock. He had no authority to fill a vacant elective office, but he can appoint anyone to his staff and give him whatever title he fancies. We hope that Paterson takes advantage of Ravitch’s abilities to assist him in managing the executive branch, which has needed more coordination since the departure last fall of the talented Father Charles O’Byrne.

Appropriately, the siege of the Democratic Party in the Senate ended not with a bang, but with a whimper, as party leaders met the terms imposed by the pirate Espada.

The 31 hostages were released, and allowed to resume their leadership positions. The exception, of course, was Malcolm Smith, the former captain, whose place will be taken by the prime mutineer, Pedro Espada, Jr. of the Bronx, the first Latino to achieve such eminence in New York State.

The Democrats will continue to spin, possibly proclaiming, or hinting, that Espada will be leader in name (and lulu) only, and that the real decisions will be made by the new Conference leader, Senator John Sampson. Watch Sampson try to cobble together the 32 votes needed to pass legislation. He will need every amigo, every blue dog, every red dog, every yellow dog, every lame dog and every corrupt dog in the razor-thin Democratic party. How much each vote will cost him and the lobbyists, is an open question.

Among the Senators who appear to have lost prestige are the so-called Reform Democrats who, despite their professions of higher ethical standards, never publicly distanced themselves from the least reputable members in their party. Nor did they ever issue a statement of their own principles or beliefs. They did not join with the June 8 Republican majority, even though it would have given them the best opportunity to pass the gay marriage bill, to which they all give lip service. They just spun their wheels for a month, until Espada returned to the reservation, thus rendering them irrelevant.

The Daily News captured the issue in an editorial, “Zero From Zeroes”:”And so it ended as it began, with a dirty, dastardly, disgraceful deal by a pack of self-important dunces who accomplished precisely nothing positive after making a mockery of the state Senate for 31 days.

“The Democrats put the house back in operation not only by welcoming back into their fold the traitorous, treacherous Pedro Espada, but also by rewarding his extortion with a promotion to majority leader…

“Those who pretend to self-respect – senators like Tom Duane, Eric Schneiderman and Liz Krueger – ought to be mortified that they are captained by a creep, and that they have lacked the guts to raise a peep in objection.”

“La Commedia e Finita,” for the moment anyway. Espada and his companion Monserrate are the clear winners, jumping the Falls and successfully returning. They hope to do as well with the juries they may face as they did with their fellow legislators, but it is their colleagues who are their peers more than the public. Kruger and Diaz, their amigo associates, also fared well. As usual, the sheep were the losers.

A question remains: If the Senate ever gets back to work, who will be the third man in the room with Governor Paterson and Speaker Silver?

When I, as City Councilman at Large, visited the office of Deputy Mayor Stanley Friedman in 1975, he had a sign on his wall: “Crime Doesn’t Pay – As Well as Politics.”

After watching Albany in 2009, I understand what he meant. The plot is the same. Nothing has changed but the names of the characters.

StarQuest@NYCivic.org

Not4Publication.com by Dom Nunziato
Michael Schenkler can be reached via this contact form.