Queens Tribune
 
....June 22, 2:53 PM
 
 
 
Willets Point Update: City Begins Talks With Biz Owners, Yet Many Say They Refuse To Budge

Many of the business owners feel violated by the city’s plans.

By JAMES J. PARZIALE

Anthony Fodera’s company sits in Willets Point, the 75-acre chunk of land now in the midst of the tug-of-war between local businesses and City legislators. The bakery ingredients provider – along with other businesses there – might be asked to leave the area because of the City’s Willets Point development plan that would breathe new life into the dilapidated region.

When asked if he plans on leaving anytime soon, Fodera posed the same question he asks anybody wondering what it is like to be in his shoes.

“If it was your home, would you let them take it?” he asked.

And so the debate waged on Tuesday night during the Willets Point Community Workshop at St. Mark AME Church in Jackson Heights. The gathering included area businesses, residents and legislators all trying to find common ground. Much of the discourse involved meeting the needs of these businesses that would be uprooted, their view on why the plan is flawed and what should be rectified.

The City’s plan involves a slew of uses: 5,500 residential units, 1.7 million square feet of retail and entertainment, nearly 1 million square feet devoted to offices and a convention center, a 650-seat school, a hotel, a park and eight acres of open space. Undoubtedly, it would create a bustling hub.

But is this massive, revenue-generating redevelopment of a neglected area – an eyesore to its neighbors – fair to the businesses in Willets Point? The future of the 250-or-so businesses and their employees in the area was the general outcry at the meeting.



Public Outcry

Though the workshop allowed members of the community to discuss solutions to the plan’s problems, the public’s resistance was prevalent. Many of the local business owners said they feel their civil rights are being trampled.

Jack Bono, who owns Bono Sawdust Company, which has been in Willets Point for 74 years, has visions of passing the business down to his son, Jake. He said the Economic Development Corporation, which is overseeing the Willets Point project and is meeting with area businesses to help with relocation packages, can offer him “an island in the Bahamas,” but he would not move.

“We don’t want to know about any monetary package,” Bono said. “We want to stay at what’s ours. They are doing a great injustice to our future by stealing our property.”

Andy Charidemou and Charalambos Gorgiou, who have owned a Sunoco station on Northern Boulevard for 27 years, said they feel this sets a bad precedent for what the City could do in the future.

“We’re talking about something that belongs to us,” Charidemou said. Later he got up and spoke to the crowd of close to 300 people and said: “What happens when [City officials say] they want to take your house? Will you let them do it?”

Fodera, one of the first business owners to meet with the EDC, said little came from the meeting. No offer was made, and he wouldn’t listen if it was on the table.

“My property is not blighted; it’s not polluted. It’s not environmentally destroyed. My partner and I spend a great deal of money up keeping the property,” said Fodera, who pays $165,000 in property taxes each year and has no sewers, no road and no sanitation service. “They never show my building when they make their presentations,” he said. “I wonder why? We all know the reason.”

Daniel Sanbucci, president of Sanbucci Bros. Salvage Yards, said his clientele is located in Queens, so a move to another borough would torpedo his business. He would not be opposed to relocating if the he is given fair value for his land, but said the City’s plan to rezone the land after the current businesses move would shortchange whatever package is offered.

“How do you take property from one private person and give it to another private person?” he asked. “It makes no sense.”



Where They Work And Live

Aside from removing businesses, other concerns were voiced at the workshop, primarily concerning the 5,500 units of housing. Affordable housing is already at a premium in Queens, and residents quipped that Willets Point will out-price most local people in need of living accommodations.

Councilman Tony Avella (D-Bayside) explained why the current system, which uses the average median income of all of Queens to determine the cost of affordable housing, is flawed. It includes incomes from upper echelon neighborhoods like Douglaston, Forest Hills Gardens, Little Neck and Jamaica Estates while trying to site homes near poorer neighborhoods of Corona and Elmhurst.

As Chairman of the City Council Zoning Committee, Avella contended that affordable housing should be calculated using the local median income, or the income from that zip code. That’s the only way to get “truly affordable housing,” and the only way he would vote for the Willets Point Development.

In addition, if businesses relocated, most of the workers would lose their current jobs. EDC spokeswoman Yonit Golub said new jobs would be created because of the retail development. In addition, the EDC would offer job training workshops to assist people in getting new jobs.

Water Rate Hike Town Hall Meeting

FDNY Implements New Dispatch System

Two Arrested In Internet Sting

Hit-And-Run Driver Turns Himself In

Media Piracy Penalties Stiffened

Budget Halts College Services

Classic Picasso Prints On Display

Harassed Tenants Building Support

Treatment Lessens Side Effects

Youth Baseball Conflicts Queens

Mets And Amazing Schools:

City Announces Rockaway Ferry

30th Candidates Squabble Over Details

Water Board Blasted For Rate Hike

Supermarket Stiffs Baggers

Katz Has Baby Boy

New Bank Offers Loans To The Poor

Senate Approves Summer Gas-Tax Suspense

Queens Inaugurates Its Jazz Orchestra

New Treatment Battles Epilepsy

City Provides Youth With Summer Jobs

Queens Air Gets an ‘F’ Report Says

Acquittals Cap Dramatic Bell Trial

 
 

Business owners and community members discuss solutions.


The EDC’S Perspective

EDC’s Willets Point Project Manger David Brito said the broad development goals at Willets Point would create too many positives for Queens to leave the area as-is. It creates “a destination, a better area, better transit,” and much more.

With the Mets’ new home, CitiField, set to open in the spring of 2009, there is pressure to upgrade the surrounding areas. One of the major points of interest is 126th Street, which will be transformed from the eyesore it is now to a major retail, restaurant and entertainment mecca.

“It’s the entrance to the district,” Brito said. “It’s really to leverage the huge investment that went into CitiField and the USTA. These folks come to these stadiums and get there 10 minutes before and leave 10 minutes after. That’s not benefiting the areas right now. We want to draw people into surrounding communities.”

Borough President Helen Marshall, who supports the redevelopment, said the project will improve the Queens economy.

“Looking forward, this plan is expected to create 20,000 construction jobs and 6,100 permanent jobs creating a $5 billion economic impact over the next 30 years,” she said. “It is critical that the redevelopment of Willets Point and the growth we expect the area to experience will support minority- and women-owned businesses and bring jobs to the residents of Queens.”

Brito said he recognizes that businesses don’t appreciate uncertainty of the plan, which is why the EDC began speaking with the owners more aggressively.

The EDC has kept open the lines of communication with area businesses since 2004 and is now trying to help them understand relocation plans and leverage all the city and state incentives for a move.

“We’re not starting the business relocation meetings by saying this is what you get,” Golub said. “We start out by saying tell us what you need.”

“No one is under the illusion that this is going to be an easy task, but the goal is to keep them as close as possible,” Brito said. “We’re trying to negotiate with all the businesses to get something that both sides are happy with…there are no guarantees that we’ll make them happy.”

“We’re going to make every effort to negotiate individually with these businesses to settle this through a private transaction,” Brito said. “Obviously, if there are one or two holdouts we’re not going to scrap the plan. It’s a wholesale redevelopment. If eminent domain is required, it’ll be used, but that’s a long way until that question is before us.”



Eyeing The Finish Line

The timeline to break ground on the project is still in the air, but the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure is set to begin this fall. That gives the local businesses and communities a short window to have their voices heard about what they truly want done with the land.

Golub said remediation of the site, which needs to be raised by four or five feet, likely wouldn’t start until 2010.

The divisive issue has many sides left to be heard and wrinkles to be ironed out, but the idea is fairness and equity for all parties involved.

“This project would be good for the city. I’m not going to deny it, I just don’t want to be a casualty of it,” Sanbucci said. “We should not be displaced and not make our end on the deal. They’re not going to stop because one person doesn’t want to move, but then they can afford to do the right thing by us.”