Queens Tribune
 
....March 9, 5:58 PM
 
 
   
Under Investigation: Queens Assemblyman Brian McLaughlin Target Of FBI Streetlight Bid-Rigging Probe

McLaughlin’s district office. Tribune photo by Ira Cohen

By ANDREW MOESEL

Just after dawn last Thursday, a team of FBI agents raided the offices of the New York City Central Labor Council, pulling out dozens of boxes brimming with files and paperwork. Employees were told to leave and the sidewalks outside the building became crowded with reporters, cameramen and photographers.

Federal agents initially were tight lipped about the purpose behind the raid, but information slowly leaked out that it was related to an investigation involving CLC president and Queens Assemblyman Brian McLaughlin. His Flushing offices, a small storefront along Depot Road, had also been targeted in the early morning search.

Over the past week, it has been widely reported that federal and city investigators had been collaborating on a probe into an alleged bid rigging scheme in which McLaughlin may have played a central role. Details are still murky, and the popular labor leader has denied any wrongdoing.

Still, the buzz of union corruption has a familiar ring in this City, and suspicions have been enough to force McLaughlin, a usually well liked and public figure, to adopt a low profile. Telling from the stacks of papers that the FBI carted away, it could be months before an official case materializes or the truth is revealed.

A Loose Rigging
Authorities are saying that McLaughlin may have been involved in a plot to manipulate the bidding process for city electrical contracts, delivering lucrative projects to a select group of favored companies. No formal charges have been filed.

McLaughlin not only served as CLC president, but also held a leadership post in Local 3 of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, a branch that primarily dealt with city street lighting. That dual role could have given McLaughlin the influence to predetermine the bids from different companies competing for the same project, essentially guaranteeing a particular company would offer the lowest price and win the contract, sources said.
It remains unclear exactly how the bid rigging scheme functioned or what role McLaughlin played in the arrangement.

But as a high-ranking labor representative, McLaughlin may have been able to negotiate labor costs and lower a company’s overall expenses, sources said. The State Department of Labor sets a prevailing wage for all electricians in New York, paying $41 an hour, plus benefits. Some contractors have been known to pay less in order to make jobs affordable, however.

In a turn of irony, McLaughlin praised City Comptroller Bill Thompson for acquiring a $1.5 million settlement for a group of underpaid electrical workers just days before he would be implicated in a similar situation.

“The labor movement applauds Comptroller Thompson for his vigorous enforcement of our city’s prevailing wage laws and his courage to continually stand up for working people against seedy business interests,” McLaughlin said in a statement last week.

One City official said this investigation could lead to a Comptroller’s audit. To date the Comptroller’s office has not audited any DOT electrical contracts.

Authorities suspect that McLaughlin may have been given an American Express card – with favored contractors footing the bill – in return for his participation in the bid rigging, sources said. The office raids were an attempt to gather evidence of a paper trail linking McLaughlin to such payments or other corruption.

Union leaders aren’t buying it. Some believe the investigation could just be a fishing expedition aimed against organized labor.

“This [federal] Administration is anti-labor, and if they can embarrass an important labor leader then they will, and that’s what they are trying to do here,” said Arthur Cheliotes, president of Communication Workers of America Local 1180. “It’s like wearing a target on your back.”

Shadowy Lighting Companies
Two Queens Companies – Petrocelli Electrical Company of Long Island City and Welsbach Electric of College Point, whose offices were raided on Thursday – appear to be at the heart of the investigation.

The companies service and maintain a large part of the city’s vast network of street and traffic lighting. Petrocelli and Welsbach currently hold a combined $160 million in city contracts, records show, far more than any other companies.

Wilbur Chapman, a former commissioner of the City Department of Transportation, told the New York Post that he had been suspicious about the number of contracts that went to only two companies. He expressed relief upon learning of the probe.

“Thank God – finally,” Chapman told the Post. “I’m happy that someone from the outside is looking at the process.”
Other news outlets have reported that Petrocelli’s name at times had floated in several federal investigations into organized crime, though the company has never been officially implicated in any crime.

Lawyers representing Petrocelli said not only have no charges been filed against their clients, but federal investigators also have assured them that the company is not even a criminal target in the McLaughlin investigation. They are cooperating with investigators, lawyers said.

Welsbach officials did not return calls for comment.

Both companies have been generous contributors to McLaughlin’s political campaigns. Since 1999, State Board of Election records show that Petrocelli gave $4,500 to the Friends of Brian McLaughlin Committee, and Welsbach gave more than $18,000.

Petrocelli also donated $9,500 to Thompson’s 2005 campaign to be reelected as Comptroller, according to Campaign Finance Board filings.

$15 Sought For Newtown Creek Cleanup

Ex-Cop, Pleads Guilty In Teen Pimp Case

Queens Helps Shape Obama’s Agenda

Bank robber Sought In Two Queens Heists

Call To Free Innocent Inmates

New Bridges Roll In Over Van Wyck

Falun Gong: Opinions Clash Over Chinese Politics In Flushing

Free AirTrain Rides For Airport 60th

Queens Son Sails To Tony Nomination

Judge Honored At Queens Courthouse

Serial Rapists Terrorize Southeast Queens

World’s Fair Book Finds Missing Pieces

Willets Point Seeks Recommendations

Supreme Court Muddles State Gun Law

Home Run For Queens Boys And Girls Club

Assemblywoman Hit By Car

Candidates Get Ready To Rumble

Domestic Violence Center Opens In Queens

Queens Family Mourns Loss Of Soldier

Cemetery Buried In Property Debate

Recent Hate Crimes Spur Local Reaction

Queens Reacts To Passing Of City Budget

Cut The Cost And Time Of Transportation

 
 

A record of McLaughlin’s bills and awards lines his Flushing office. Tribune photo by Ira Cohen

Laying Low
Since taking the helm of the CLC in 1994, McLaughlin has been the public face of the New York labor movement. In addition to political stops, he makes as many public appearances as perhaps any official in the City, lending his time to scores of union events.

But the sudden investigation, which surprised many union officials, caused him to vanish from the public eye. He skipped a scheduled appearance at a fund-raiser for Cheliotes the morning of the raid, taking place only blocks from the CLC offices. Informed he would not attend, transport union leaders postponed a rally a Brooklyn Borough Hall.

His whereabouts remained a mystery over the weekend, but this week he began reporting to work at the CLC, sources said.

New York State AFL-CIO president David Hughes said he believes it would be wise to extend McLaughlin’s public hiatus, however. He is circulating a proposal among union officials that would allow McLaughlin retain his official position as president while having another labor official, Ed Ott, attend public events.

At an emergency meeting this week to discuss the handling of the federal probe, officials voted to hire attorney Paul Shechtman of Stillman & Friedman to represent the board before federal officials. That decision and any others regarding the investigation would need to be ratified by the Council’s March 16 executive board meeting.

McLaughlin has not appeared in Albany since the raid, but sources said he was expected to return sometime next week.
The Assemblyman stunned many colleagues only weeks ago by announcing his intention to forgo re-election in the fall. McLaughlin said he planned to spend more time with family and to focus on his union role.

Holding both positions had been lucrative for McLaughlin, who earns $96,000 a year for his work in Albany and an additional $167,000 for his union post. He owns houses in Flushing, Long Island and Florida.

In a meeting with local reporters in January, McLaughlin stressed that his union ties never influenced his impartiality as a lawmaker. His decision to leave office was not connected to knowledge of the investigation, a spokesperson said.

Before last week, McLaughlin enjoyed both a spotless reputation and the respect of his political colleagues. More than that, though, he was almost universally admired, giving the recent developments a sense of sadness as well as disappointment.

“Everybody knew Brian is a friendly guy. Nobody suspected that he would do something like this,” said an Albany official. “We’re all kind of hoping that [the allegations] aren’t true.”

[Feature Archives]