Queens Tribune
 
....July 13, 3:17 PM
 
 
 
Going, Going, Gone: Trees On St. Saviour Site Removed, Community Keeps Pushing To Protect

Previously hidden behind the trees, St. Saviour’s Church is revealed. Tribune photo by Ira Cohen

By MICHAEL CUSENZA

One could practically envision Mayor Mike Bloomberg’s face cringing with every revolution of the chainsaw, and shuddering at the cold sound of branches snapping from their foundations.

Suffice it to say that large, ominous tree and shrubbery removal trucks weren’t quite what the Mayor had in mind when he presented his plan earlier this year to forge a “greener” New York City.

But that was the scene on Tuesday and Wednesday at St. Saviour’s Church and Parsonage in Maspeth, as crews began cutting, chopping and razing the 185 trees, many of which are more than 100 years old, on the historic property where several Civil War relics and Spanish coins have also been unearthed.

The Juniper Park Civic Association and its Committee to Save St. Saviour’s had just held its third rally July 1 outside the 1.5-acre piece of land located at 57-40 58th St.

Is It Too Late?

As of Tuesday morning it seemed that all the campaigning, letter-writing and rallying to save the settlement from demolition just wasn’t going to be enough. Approximately one quarter of the trees, including the oldest on the property, in the southwest corner had been removed.

City Councilman Tony Avella (D-Bayside) does not represent Maspeth or Middle Village but has stood with the active civic association on St. Saviour’s and other land preservation issues. The 2009 mayoral candidate has rallied against overdevelopment since he took office in 2001, and Wednesday asked that the developer “immediately halt any and all actions, including the removal of trees, as it relates to this property.”

Avella and all of the volunteers who have dedicated themselves to reclaiming the land for the community were understandably shaken by Tuesday’s development, but vowed it will not deter them.

“We’re definitely not going to stop fighting,” Christina Wilkinson, chairperson of the Committee to Save St. Saviour’s, declared.

Wilkinson also pointed out that the destruction of the trees is a violation of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, which decreed that all migratory birds and their parts, including eggs, nests and feathers, were fully protected.

“It’s horrendous that they would choose nesting season to do this,” she said. “They’re killing birds and it’s illegal.”

A Colorful History

St. Saviour’s Church and Parsonage was designed by renowned 19th century architect Richard Upjohn and consecrated an Episcopal church in 1848. In 1878, according to Forgotten New York, to which Wilkinson contributes, James Maurice donated the land on which the parsonage sits and the 80 additional wooded acres to the church with the intention that part of the land would be used for a seminary. The 1878 deed states that the land may only be used for a church.

“Historically, this is a very important area of Queens,” said Jim Driscoll, president of the Queens Historical Society.

Seminerio Steps Down, Pleads Guilty

Hundreds Get In Line For Handful Of Jobs

Man Caught On Video Trashing Political Signs

Hiram Claims Reform, Dems Disagree

City Geese Removal Not Linked To Trash

Public Art Installation Destroyed By Vandals

Facing Foreclosure? Find Help With 311

Judge OKs Vantage Tenants’ Lawsuit

Iranian Election Votes Cast In Queens

Centers Saved But Programs Face Cut

COBRA Coverage May Be Extended

BP Offers Guide On Immigrant Aid

Mayoral Control Saga Winding Down

Back To School After Graduation?

Amigos Strike Back: Albany In Chaos After Monday’s Coup

Boro Loses A Soldier Serving In Afghanistan

Maloney Poll Shows Edge Over Gillibrand

Jamaica High School On the Rebound

Hearings Set For Waste Transfer Station

Sanitation Commish Defending Trash Plan

Vantage Response System Earns Praise

Avella’s Existence Doubles Thompson’s $$

Queens School Ready For The Bronx

 
 

Tree and shrubbery removal truck at St. Saviour’s. Tribune photo by Ira Cohen


In 1996 St. Saviour’s was sold to Korean Methodist Church for $450,000. It was sold again to Maspeth Development, LLC in 2005 for $6 million.

Since then, the future of the land has remained in a state of uncertainty.

Reasons For Preservation

The debate over St. Saviour’s is, in essence, a classic case of preservation vs. development. The JPCA, in conjunction with the community surrounding the embattled land, believes St. Saviour’s should be converted into a park, museum and community center. They have asked the City to acquire the land and move forward with that preservation plan.

The developer, meanwhile, wants to obtain the proper zoning change from manufacturing to residential and construct affordable housing units. This request has remained stalled in City Planning for two years.

The JPCA managed to stave off full demolition of St. Saviour’s earlier this year, and a stop work order for the land remains on record on the Department of Buildings Web site.

The JPCA is fighting not only to preserve a historic piece of property, but to beautify an overwhelmingly industrial neighborhood they feel is desperate for park land.

“There are a lot of things in the neighborhood that are not good,” JCPA President Robert Holden said, referring to the railroad tracks, factories and truck route that surround the site. “Is it too much to ask for a sanctuary for our health and preservation?”

Wilkinson cited how the demolition of St. Saviour’s in favor of development flies in the face of the Mayor’s 2030 Plan to make the City more eco-friendly.

“There are children playing in Grainger’s parking lot and on the railroad tracks,” she said at the most recent rally. “I want to know why they can’t have [a park] so they can be somewhere safe.”



Can There Be Compromise?

In an effort to compromise, the developer proposed to save the church edifice and build around it. Wilkinson called this a “ridiculous proposal,” convinced that once the zoning change was approved the developer would continue to demolish the church.

The JPCA also came up with its own proposal: a land swap, should the City not be able to fund the acquisition of the land. But the Mayor’s office has yet to respond to this idea.

“It seems as if [Bloomberg] has turned his back on us,” Wilkinson said before outlining the “win-win-win” outcome of a land swap deal.

“The developer can turn a profit, the City gets a park and the community gets green space,” she explained.

Avella, JPCA’s “2006 Man of the Year” and chair of the City Council’s Zoning and Franchises committees, has been working with the City and the developer to facilitate the land swap.

“I would hope that the developer would recognize the benefit of working with the community and not against it,” Avella said.



Remaining Resolute

At least one thing remained clear Wednesday afternoon: despite this week’s setback, the community’s resolve has not waned and the fight to save St. Saviour’s is far from over.

JPCA and the Committee began their quest more than a year ago, and it’s obvious when speaking to her about St. Saviour’s that Wilkinson and her supporters have developed a connection, a real affinity, for the land that has become much more than just trees and dilapidated buildings.

That’s why Tuesday and Wednesday’s tree-chopping really cut close to home.

“It’s like watching somebody die and you can’t do anything about it,” Wilkinson concluded. “You feel very helpless.”