|
|
| |
Building & Lone: Neighbors Harmed By Illegal Work Must Face Ill Effects On Their Own
|
| Reuben’s backyard is beginning to sink due to construction next door.
|
By LIZ SKALKA
It began as a scenario familiar to many Queens residents: another new development, another large home changing the face of middle-class neighborhoods across the borough.
But for Joan Reuben, a Flushing resident, a new development in her neighborhood she said costs $3 million has had an increasingly negative impact.
Because of construction taking place to the rear of her home, the foundation of her property has been undermined. Reuben received a vacate order from the Department of Buildings last month for her garage and her backyard has begun to sink.
She is disturbed by what she sees as anything but neighborly interactions.
“How would you like your neighbor to do that to your house?” Reuben asked rhetorically. “It’s not nice.”
She estimates the cost to repair the damages at around $50,000. “How would you like to pull that out of your pocket on a random day?” she asked.
Her only option at this point, Reuben said, may be to pay out of pocket to repair the damages or to sue the owner. Her homeowner’s insurance may not cover the repairs.
Problems Brewing
The trouble began in May when construction started at 33-33 165th St., to the rear of Reuben’s home on 166th St. She said she knew from the start of the ordeal that trouble was afoot.
“It felt like an extended earthquake,” she said of the initial days of construction. “Everything was shaking.”
Shortly after, Reuben’s husband noticed a crack in their retaining wall in the back of their property. In June, her backyard began to sink.
“We had no idea we would be so susceptible or vulnerable to something like this,” she noted.
Reuben said she then contacted the Department of Buildings and both the department as well as the builder promised to help remedy the problem. So far, Reuben said, no one has come through on their assurances.
The Buildings Department then stopped responding to her calls and letters, Rueben said, so she contacted the fire department. She said the FDNY was able to get someone from the Buildings Department out to her home, who on Sept. 20 issued a vacate order for her garage, though Reuben insists her garage hasn’t yet presented a problem.
Reuben doesn’t yet wish to disclose how she plans to proceed with the problem, but said that she fears if the hole in her yard isn’t fixed it will get worse in the winter months.
Hefty Violations
The property at 33-33 165th St. currently has a partial-stop work order issued on it, though Reuben said she hears work being done there most days.
According to the Buildings Department, there are nine Environmental Control Board violations issued and 12 complaints logged for the site. Several pertain to the crack in Reuben’s retaining wall. One was for not installing a fence properly at the site.
Reuben also pointed out that since construction began several stop work orders have been issued.
Calls were made to the property’s owner, Kyung Won Min, for this article and were never returned.
Reuben said Min and the builders are to blame for the problems and the Buildings Department should come to her aid.
A representative from the Buildings Department responded, “The owner has a responsibility under the law to maintain his or her building in a safe and lawful condition. The best recourse for owners whose properties have been damaged by neighboring construction is civil court.”
The representative noted that New York City residents should call 311 to report violations, such as working against a stop work order. They should dial 911 if a site poses an immediate threat to safety.
|
|
Water Rate Hike Town Hall Meeting
FDNY Implements New Dispatch System
Two Arrested In Internet Sting
Hit-And-Run Driver Turns Himself In
Media Piracy Penalties Stiffened
Budget Halts College Services
Classic Picasso Prints On Display
Harassed Tenants Building Support
Treatment Lessens Side Effects
Youth Baseball Conflicts Queens
Mets And Amazing Schools:
City Announces Rockaway Ferry
30th Candidates Squabble Over Details
Water Board Blasted For Rate Hike
Supermarket Stiffs Baggers
Katz Has Baby Boy
New Bank Offers Loans To The Poor
Senate Approves Summer Gas-Tax Suspense
Queens Inaugurates Its Jazz Orchestra
New Treatment Battles Epilepsy
City Provides Youth With Summer Jobs
Queens Air Gets an ‘F’ Report Says
Acquittals Cap Dramatic Bell Trial
|
| |
|
|
| A stop work order was issued for the construction site.
|
A Larger Issue
But as Councilman Tony Avella (D-Bayside) has pointed out, calling 311 often doesn’t produce immediate action. Sometimes it can be too late to issue a violation before damage has occurred. Reuben has found a supporter recently in local representatives including Avella, who said the Buildings Department should not leave the burden of paying for the damages on Reuben or on homeowners in similar situations.
“The City has to come to the aid of homeowners,” he said. “If she were the victim of a crime, the police would come to her aid. This is a crime.”
“The City is turning a blind eye,” he added, referring to Reuben’s recent trouble in contacting the Buildings Department.
Reuben and others pointed out that the damages that happened to her home are not uncommon. Professionals that have assessed her damages have indicated the same.
“This is a problem throughout the City,” said Mel Siegel, president of the Broadway-Flushing Homeowners Association.
Avella and Siegel accused Mayor Mike Bloomberg’s administration of having a pro-development stance, which they believe is destroying quaint middle-class neighborhoods and spurring the development of larger homes that, during their construction, may violate building codes.
“I’ve heard developers say, ‘I’ll pay the $1,000 fine, I’m going to make a half a million on this house,’” Siegel said, and added, “It’s a big problem because people want these huge houses.”
Siegel and his organization are trying to get his section of Flushing turned into a landmark district to prevent excessive building.
Corey Bearak, president of the Queens Civic Congress, said out-of-character development is a huge problem in Queens.
“The interpretation of the zoning regulation today is different,” Bearak said. “It’s construction that once seemed not to be legal is legal nowadays.” He added that new developments are often “inappropriate in context next to other developments.”
As for Reuben, she just wants her home repaired. “How can this be allowed? How is it that this is okay?” she asked. “It’s not just about property. It’s devastating. You’re home is your biggest investment.” |
|
| |
|
|
|