|
|
| |
Bell Tolls For Cops: Three Indicted In Death Of Groom As Community Awaits Queens Trial
|
| Brooklyn Councilman Charles Barron says the charges are not strong enough.
|
By MATT HAMPTON
The grand jury unsealed the indictments in the Sean Bell case Monday, ending days of speculation as to the potential charges and months of questions surrounding the Nov. 25 shooting.
Eight total charges were filed, with Detectives Mike Oliver and Gescard Isnora both facing first-degree manslaughter, and Detective Marc Cooper charged with two counts of reckless endangerment. On Nov. 25, the night of the incident, Oliver and Isnora fired 31 and 11 shots respectively and Cooper fired four times. The two other officers involved in the incident were not charged.
Isnora and Oliver face a maximum sentence of 25 years if convicted, while Cooper, charged with two Class A misdemeanors, would face a maximum of one year.
“Our investigation into the death of Sean Bell and the wounding of Trent Benefield and Joseph Guzman on Nov. 25, 2006 on Liverpool Street in South Jamaica was as thorough and complete as I’ve ever participated in,” Queens DA Richard Brown said, opening the proceedings. He outlined the charges in order of severity, and the actions the officers took that led to each filing.
Aside from first-degree manslaughter, Oliver faces a second-degree count of the same charge as well as two counts of first-degree assault and a pair of reckless endangerment charges. Isnora faces second-degree manslaughter, first- and second-degree assault, and second-degree reckless endangerment.
Calls For Calm
After the indictment, Mayor Michael Bloomberg issued a statement, urging understanding in the community, and a belief that the judicial process needs to continue unabated.
“After hearing the case presented by the Queens District Attorney, the Grand Jury has spoken,” Bloomberg said. “Although some people will be disappointed in the Grand Jury’s decision, we have to respect the result of our justice system.” Bloomberg also added that while nothing can rectify the loss of Bell, there are lessons the city can take from the events.
Police Commissioner Ray Kelly also issued a statement as the NYPD announced an internal investigation into the events that had occurred on Nov. 25. He also said that the non-indicted officers had been reassigned, and that the Oliver, Cooper and Isnora had been suspended without pay.
A throng of reporters, photographers and news cameras gathered to hear the presentation of the charges, and the NAACP, with the People’s Justice Coalition, gathered at the steps of the Courthouse to demonstrate.
Charges Lack Strength?
“I don’t think that’s satisfying for me,” said Carmen Davila, of the Bronx, when informed of the charges. “They’re police officers, they’re supposed to honor and protect the people, and they did the opposite.”
Three young protestors staged an act of civil disobedience on the courthouse steps, loudly chanting “No justice, no peace,” before being arrested by a group of about 10 officers. The three protestors, Camila Gelpi-Acosta, Vincente Alba and Rafael Toruellas, from Brooklyn and the Bronx, were taken into custody quickly after beginning their demonstration, and a large group of police officers then gated off the steps of the building.
“It was perfectly peaceful, they were not resisting arrest; they were there to get arrested,” said Claudia Delacruz, of Washington Heights, who had arrived with the other protestors.
“Most people don’t want to get arrested, [but] most people do want to see justice,” said Councilman James Sanders (D-Laurelton). “Civil disobedience is just one of the strategies in a case like this.”
Councilman Sanders had arrived at the courthouse by himself to hear the indictments directly from DA Brown, but was kept waiting unhappily outside.
|
|
City Announces Rockaway Ferry
30th Candidates Squabble Over Details
Water Board Blasted For Rate Hike
Supermarket Stiffs Baggers
Katz Has Baby Boy
New Bank Offers Loans To The Poor
Senate Approves Summer Gas-Tax Suspense
Queens Inaugurates Its Jazz Orchestra
New Treatment Battles Epilepsy
City Provides Youth With Summer Jobs
Queens Air Gets an ‘F’ Report Says
Acquittals Cap Dramatic Bell Trial
Libertarians Unite In Queens
Controversy Spreads Over Campus Name
Mayor Praises Flood Task Force Effort
Schools Are Out Of Touch
Con Ed Agrees to Pay $63 Million
Cable Companies Fight For Franchise
Residents Want School Boards Back
NYRA Ushers In New Era At Belmont
Access-A-Ride Process Under Fire
U.S. Treasurer Visits Queens
Special Election Set For June 3
|
| |
|
|
|
| Bishop Lester Williams and Sean Bell’s parents.
|
“This [incident] is a symbol to people, this is not an isolated case,” he said. “This had been the straw that had broken the camel’s back.”
Councilman Sanders is the city representative of both the late Sean Bell and Joseph Guzman. He said he thought the entire Southeast Queens community was likely to be on edge.
As the crowd of demonstrators on the courthouse steps began to grow, the rhetoric did the same, punctuated by a speech from representatives of the People’s Justice Coalition, and Councilman Charles Barron (D-Brooklyn).
“We will be on the streets until we get justice,” said Rosa Clemente, of the People’s Justice Coalition. “Manslaughter is not justice.”
Councilman Barron seconded the sentiment, with a portent of impending unrest.
“We are going to keep the heat on the street, and if need be, we are going to become ungovernable,” he warned. “DA Brown has committed a travesty of justice. They are setting [the trial] up for them to get a slap on the wrist or walk.”
“If you think I’m bad,” he added, “keep this up and see what comes out of this community.”
Civil Ceremony
As Queensites took in the events of the day, the three officers were arraigned at the Queens County Courthouse Monday afternoon. According to published reports, Guzman and Benefield sat in the courtroom with Bell’s parents when the charges were unsealed.
Bishop Lester Williams, pastor to the Bell family, and the man who was scheduled to marry Sean and Nicole Paultre Bell, was also with Bell’s parents in the courtroom.
Bishop Williams described the family pallor as “very somber, very staid.” He also said that the family had been visibly shaken to hear the charges.
“It was very emotional to hear those charges read,” Williams said. “I don’t think you ever get over this.”
All three of the accused officers entered pleas of not guilty, and were freed on bond.
“I would’ve liked to have seen murder charges,” Williams added, echoing the sentiments of many community members who felt the indictments did not go far enough. “We’ll take what we can get at this point.”
Williams said he was concerned about “rampant retaliation” within the community, and added that “you can sense the tension” in the Southeast Queens areas impacted by decisions in the case. The situation was not helped, he said, by a story that appeared in Sunday’s New York Post, depicting Detective Mike Oliver at the center of a $4,200 dinner on the Upper East Side.
“That type of reveling appears to be a gloat,” Williams said.
SEQ Stands By DA
The Robert Ross Johnson Family Life Center on Linden Boulevard in Southeast Queens played host to a community meeting and speak-out after the charges had been unsealed, the first official opportunity for community members to debate the charges that had been filed.
Clergy, community residents and members of the City Council were all given equal opportunity to voice an opinion. U.S. Rep. Gregory Meeks (D-St. Albans) hosted the event, which was attended by Borough President Helen Marshall and Councilmen Tom White, Leroy Comrie and James Sanders, among others.
Starting from the moment the exact charges were revealed, there had been speculation about a possible change of venue for the trial, as was the case in the trial of the officers charged in the slaying of Amadou Diallo. Michael Palladino, of the Detectives Endowment Association, has already made a case for a change of venue, saying that there is no viable way that an impartial jury could be found in a county so saturated with media coverage.
Southeast Queens residents and leaders felt differently, however, as did DA Brown, who said he would strongly oppose any motion to move the trial to a new venue.
“We look forward to a fair and impartial trial to take place right here in Queens County,” said Meeks.
“Yes, you can have a fair trial in Queens,” Councilman Sanders said, citing the diversity of the county. “If you can’t have a fair trial in Queens, there is nowhere to have a fair trial.” |
[Feature
Archives] |
|